Royalties and DRM: The Birth of DRM
Today's term
DRM (digital rights management): copy and play limits, licence counts, rentals that expire, online payment and automatic royalty accounting.
In plain words
The card itself can count how many digital copies are made and stop at a set maximum, so the copyright owner can prevent unlicensed copying. The 1979 report adds paid play limits, automatic billing and royalty splits.
Kane Kramer
“As far as I know, this is the first example of what became DRM; if anyone has verifiable earlier evidence, I invite them to show it.”
What the sources cover
In the patent text (same passage in EP 0 092 558 B1, col. 5, ll. 51-59). The patent limits the number of digital reproductions (copies) and names "the owner of copyright sound data"; payment appears as "appropriate money or credit card". The 1979 report builds on this with paid play limits ("5 ot 10 plays", typed as in the original), billing and royalty splitting.
- Patent: a count of digital reproductions, capped at a set maximum, so the copyright owner can prevent unlicensed copying; payment by money or credit card.
- 1979 report: paid play limits, billing and royalty splits.
The blueprint wording · exact text, number and location
“The controller 34 could be programmed to keep a count of the number of times that digital data is reproduced, and if desired to cease to allow further such reproductions above a specified maximum number of times; thus the owner of copyright sound data could prevent unlicensed copying, since a copy of satisfactory quality can only be made from the digital data, not from the normal analogue output.”
PATENT · US 4,667,088 · col. 5, ll. 15-22“In this mode, the controller 34 could be programmed to keep a count of the number of times that digital data is reproduced, and if desired to cease to allow further such reproductions above a specified maximum number of time; thus the owner of copyright sound data could prevent unlicensed copying, since a copy of satisfactory quality can only be made from the digital data, not from the normal analogue output.”
PATENT · GB 2 115 996 A · p. 3, ll. 27-35“upon insertion of appropriate money or credit card”
PATENT · US 4,667,088 · col. 6, ll. 44-51“Because of the programmable nature of the IXI CHIP, the record company can present artists work to the consumer in the most lucrative form by varying the content, number and prices charged for each "track". e.g. 5 or 3 or 1 preferred track from an album, or even 5 ot 10 plays of your preference and the card would destruct the memory when the last play has completed.”
1979 REPORT · IXI Systems outline report (1979) · typed p.6 (PDF p.8)“It calculates and bills the retailers account, splits the relative apportionments of PRS, Artists Royalties, writers and record companies share, all in a matter of seconds.”
1979 REPORT · IXI Systems outline report (1979) · typed p.1 (PDF p.3)“On completion of the information transfer, the terminal and central data bank communicate with each other to provide sales chart updating, retailer billing, commission and royalty accounting.”
1979 REPORT · IXI Systems outline report (1979) · typed p.5 (PDF p.7)