Press
1985 to 1987The cover lists the issue's features, producers, engineers and studios, including Digital Futures.
Read the text
December 1985, £1.20
SOUND ENGINEER + PRODUCER
Producer of the Year: Chart Analysis
Weller's Solid Bond: A Family Affair
The Gear: Rebis/Akai, Samplers, Fostex, Synchronisers, TC Spatial Expander
The Producers: Langer & Winstanley, Don Was, Alan Shacklock
The Engineer: Damien Korner
The Studios: Solid Bond, Workhouse, Westheath
The Features: Mixdown, Mixing Desk Guide, Paul Hardcastle, Digital Futures
The Professional's Guide to Pro Audio
Kane Kramer holds the prototype. Its front panel reads I.X.I. DIGITAL SYSTEMS.
Read the text
On the front panel: I.X.I. DIGITAL SYSTEMS. The three slots are numbered 1, 2 and 3, and the keypad is labelled A, B, C and D. A smaller line under the name [illegible].
The photograph carries no article text.
Report on the IXI prototype from Lyric Data of London: digital stereo on chip cartridges, three held at once, 10 minutes each.
Read the text
Waxing lyrical over card-carried music
By Noel Keywood
IF YOU thought the future of music recording was a battle between compact discs and digital audio tapes, reconsider. This week a team of British entrepreneurs unveils the most radical system yet: a music recorder on a chip.
The prototype IXI comes from Lyric Data of London, where Kane Kramer and James Campbell have spent the past few years working on a system which could record, play and re-record music on a sliver of plastic with a chip in it, like a credit card.
The IXI is the first commercially viable version. It produces high-quality digital stereo from cartridges slightly smaller than video cassettes. Three are held in a player at once and each plays for 10 minutes so half an hour's playing time can be achieved by "cascading", or running them together. Kramer, Lyric's managing director, and Campbell, who is technical director, are convinced that a model which works for up to an hour will be a reality within two years.
Current tape machines and disc players, or "boxes of wheels" as the consumer electronics industry dubs them, are, in comparison, expensive to make, bulky, noisy and wear out. They are bound eventually to be superseded by "solid-state" chip based systems: electronic systems with no moving parts. Video recording will go the same way.
The problem Lyric Data reckons it has solved is that of the huge volume of storage needed: 600m binary digits of information for each 10 minutes of music. This is way in excess of the biggest memory chips yet. Campbell and Kramer's solution uses inexpensive standard memory chips, each of which holds around 1m binary digits. About 600 of these are joined in one package.
The chips can be wiped clean by an electrical signal, then re-recorded, having an operating life "in excess of five thousand passes," according to Campbell.
Lyric Data is holding talks with three different chip manufacturers for the revolutionary music memory device. But it says potential manufacturers are nervous about tying up a large part of their output with this as yet unproven technology.
The Sunday Times tested an earlier system which played 16 seconds of music and found the quality similar to that of a compact disc. It had a full frequency range and virtual absence of distortion and noise. "Packing in more memory will extend the playing time of production units to ten minutes," says Kramer.
At the moment the cost of one 10-minute cartridge is £3,000. While this is far too high for domestic use, it may prove acceptable to broadcasting companies for jingles and commercials where the IXI offers reliability, durability and split second, computer controlled cueing.
Photo caption: The weight of recorded music's future on their shoulders? Kramer (left) and Campbell
Kane Kramer with the prototype, reprinted. The front panel reads I.X.I. DIGITAL SYSTEMS.
Read the text
On the front panel: I.X.I. DIGITAL SYSTEMS. The three slots are numbered 1, 2 and 3. Smaller lettering under the name and at the lower left [illegible].
The image is the photograph only; its caption is shown above.
Part 2 of a feature on Lyricdata's IXI solid-state digital audio system, from a conversation with Kane Kramer.
Read the text
COMMENT
ALVIN GOLD continues the story of Lyricdata’s no-moving parts digital
recording system, the like of which may one day supersede CD and DAT
SOLID STATE
AS ADVERTISED, HERE IS PART 2 OF THE
feature on Lyricdata, started in last month’s
issue, concerning the IXI (pronounced as
‘pixie’ but without the 'p’) solid state digital
audio system. Here we flesh out the details
in a conversation with the managing
director of the company, Cane Kramer. The
interview started with a discussion of the
cartridge technology . . .
There are two types of memory that we will
employ. The more expensive of these - and
suitable production quantities are not yet
available - are electrically erasable prog-
rammable read-only memory devices -
E²PROM for short. It’s a non-volatile
memory, and it doesn’t require a battery
backup, But our initial production is much
more likely to be on something that is
available to use, that can be packaged as we
require, and that is available in the
quantities we require from a large number of
sources. With E²PROMs there isn’t the
depth of suppliers to give us the confidence to
go with them yet. But it’s undoubtedly what
we will be using in about six or nine months’
time, which will be an eternity in terms of
where we are now. Until then we'll be using
low power consumption CMOS RAM chips
with a lithium battery which will last about
10 years without recharging or changing.
"Storage capacity of the cartridges is in the
region of 800 Mbyte altogether, and it comes
as a sealed unit. The only connections are an
inset electrical contact on either side, and a
red window fitted with three little transceiv-
ers. The centre one is the clock, and the outer
two are for bi-directional transmission of
data. This will enable you, for example, to
programme a series of edits that you want in
a piece of music, and then load the
instructions off the computer, or an IXI
master module, onto the cartridge. Then, if
you take the cartridge somewhere else, it
knows what it’s supposed to do. In effect it’s
intelligent: you can programme it with
running orders. That makes the whole
system that much more versatile in the
professional arena.
"The infra-red based optical interface
itself is very cheap and operates at clock
rates well in excess of what we need - about
0.75MB/track/sec. It’s more than most -
we're running at 48kHz sampling frequency
- because we're recording one-for-one. We
use no data compression at all. We have
error correction, but it doesn’t have to be
tuned so fine because the chances of serious
errors occurring of the kind you get with tape
are infinitessimal.
"The system seems to be running almost
before we're really ready to work. We
thought others might want to license the
system perhaps 6-9 months down the road,
after we had it firmly launched into the
[column break; page footer: HI-FI ANSWERS MARCH 1987]
studios. But we realise that the agreement
has to be now.
"Pricing is a bit complicated. Starting with
a basic two-track system, you can up that to a
24 track system by adding rack mounting
units. You don’t have to put in more
microprocessors, another master controller
or a lot more clocks. All you need is extra
ADCs and DACs, and a small amount of
software in the form of a couple of E²PROMS
to cope with any new facilities it has to
accommodate. You can build the system up
as big as you want. It'll take 10 minutes of
mono. If you put in six cartridges, which is an
hour of mono, you can have 60 channels of
one minute if that’s what you want and if you
don’t mind buying the additional ADCs and
DACs.
"As a basic stereo recorder and replay unit
with no edit facilities it will cost more than a
DAT machine, but not horrendously more.
The thing that will inhibit the price in this
kind of application is the price of memory -
the cartridges - which at the start will cost
about £3,000 each. But you can do millions of
rewrites and unlimited replays, so the cost
can be amortised. And the system is so
flexible that you can do things you wouldn't
dream of doing any other way.
"The player itself would be very cheap. A
straight stereo player might cost about
£1,000 - £1,500 to start with. A recorder
needs ADCs as well, and probably quite a bit
of sophisticated editing on board, but it’s
quite straightforward with IXI to perform
some sophisticated tasks like stretching the
sound and adjusting the waveform to keep
the pitch the same, and all sorts of other
peculiar things. These facilities will appear
on a more expensive unit primarily for film
and advertis ing work - a kind of audio
Quantel (a professional video effects unit). A
basic recorder will cost about £2,500-£3,000.
An all-singing, all-dancing professional
base unit would cost about £20k, but this
really would enable you to do almost
anything.
"Compared to DAT, there are no moving
parts, no servicing, no motors, indefinite
longevity - remember there are no heads to
wear out - and digital audio quality will be
better because less error correction is
needed. And costs will fall as the cost of
memory falls. We've been doing practically
nothing but watch the price of memory
falling over the last seven years. Prices will
continue to fall and there won't be any letup.
From the portability point of view,
looking down the road a bit, you won't get all
the problems with jogging and so on that
affect CD. It will be a proper portable system.
Another advantage of IXI will be true
random access. There’s no question of
winding forward or anything like that.
When you do an edit it’s not destructive of
information. The system just relocates data
in memory.
"It's so different from RDAT. If you
imagine you have a monotrack, you can take
any piece of that track, starting anywhere
and ending anywhere. Against an eternal
clock and a trigger mechanism which is in
the internal microprocessor you can make
that passage start and stop whenever you
want. You can then have 10 bits starting and
stopping simultaneously, or allow them to
slip slightly in relation to each other. You
don't actually have tracks, though for the
purposes of the operator, it’s convenient to
think of it that way.’
For background, plans call for the IXI
system to see its first commercial applica-
tions in broadcast studios - and possibly for
data storage purposes. Lyricdata also fore-
see a consumer market, but not until the
early 1990s. One idea is to use IXI in much
the same way that the video industry deals
with films. The customer will go into a
retailer's store, and via a computer terminal
linked to a central database download any
piece of music he requires. This could be a
logical successor to the singles market.
Everything then is in stock all the time.
Certainly it would solve all kinds of
distribution problems. [continues]
[page 13]